Positive. Rolling Stone : 3.5/5. Uncut : 4/5. Widely hailed as their best since Morning Glory .
Mixed to positive. Praised for restraint but criticized for lack of anthems. Rolling Stone: 3/5. oasis studio albums
Initially positive but soon reviled. Retrospectively panned as a monument to over-indulgence. Rolling Stone gave it 3/5 at release, later downgraded. Positive
Generally favorable. Q gave 4/5. Some noted inconsistency in the second half. oasis studio albums
Mediocre. Many critics called it safe and uninspired. Pitchfork gave 4.9/10.
Instant acclaim. NME called it “a landmark album.” Praised for its confidence and hooks.