The politician’s reasoning is most vulnerable to criticism because it:
Historically, fair use was a narrow exception. However, the rise of digital technologies, from VCRs to YouTube, has expanded both the means of copying and the arguments for transformative use. The landmark 1994 Supreme Court case Campbell v. Acuff-Rose Music held that a commercial parody could be fair use if it “transforms” the original by adding new expression or meaning. This transformative use standard has since dominated fair use jurisprudence. mock lsat test
A) Only students with a valid ID can enter the library. John entered the library. Therefore, John has a valid ID. B) All members of the team have trained for at least a year. Sara has trained for two years. Therefore, Sara is a member of the team. C) If you are a citizen, you can vote. Ana can vote. Therefore, Ana is a citizen. D) The only way to win the lottery is to buy a ticket. Tom bought a ticket. Therefore, Tom will win the lottery. E) Anyone who is allergic to peanuts cannot eat this cookie. Emily ate the cookie. Therefore, Emily is not allergic to peanuts. Directions: Read the following passage and answer the questions. (This is a condensed single passage; a full LSAT RC section has 4 passages with 5–8 questions each.) Passage A (Questions 26–32) The politician’s reasoning is most vulnerable to criticism
Which of the following, if true, most strengthens the librarian’s argument? Acuff-Rose Music held that a commercial parody could
A) Adding a lane to a highway reduces congestion temporarily but induces more driving, so congestion returns. B) Lowering taxes increases consumer spending but also increases the deficit, so it harms the economy. C) Planting more trees in a city reduces air pollution but increases maintenance costs, so it is not worthwhile. D) Hiring more police officers reduces crime in the short term but may lead to over-policing, so it is undesirable. E) Building more schools increases educational access but raises taxes, so it is politically unpopular. Essayist: Some people claim that competitive sports build character. But many professional athletes have been convicted of crimes. Therefore, competitive sports do not build character.
The archaeologist’s reasoning is most vulnerable to the objection that:
A) During the three-month trial, a popular special exhibit was open only on weekends. B) Weekday attendance decreased during the trial period. C) Other museums in the city also raised weekend prices last year. D) The museum’s overall attendance has been declining for five years. E) The price increase last year was 20%, while the new increase is 50%. No one who lacks a sense of humor can be a successful comedian. Some people who are not funny have a sense of humor. Therefore, some people who are not funny cannot be successful comedians.